At a glance: This study investigates outcomes for minority ethnic and minority religion groups in Northern Ireland using information from the 2021 Census. It looks at areas such as health, disability, educational attainment, employment, and housing. The research examines how outcomes differ between groups and when compared with majority groups in the population. For minority ethnic groups, additional analysis was carried out to consider whether differences in outcomes remained when relevant factors were accounted for (e.g. age, educational qualifications, urban or rural residence).

Key findings

Overall

Differences were seen across minority ethnic and minority religion groups

Differences in outcomes were evident across minority ethnic and minority religion groups, and when compared with majority groups in the population.

Some groups were associated with less favourable outcomes (e.g. poor general health, low English language proficiency).

Other groups had more positive outcomes such as large population shares participating in the labour market and working in high-skilled occupations.

What the data show - Observed differences

Initial analysis looked at patterns in the publicly-available statistics from the 2021 Census. This showed where differences existed between both minority ethnic and minority religion groups across a range of outcomes.

Positive outcomes

The Filipino and Indian ethnic groups had more positive outcomes than the White ethnic group on several measures. For example, a smaller share reported a disability, poor general health, and having no formal qualifications.

Among the minority religion groups examined, the Hindu population generally had more positive outcomes. For example, a higher share had degree-level qualifications and worked in high-skilled occupations.

Negative outcomes

Some minority ethnic and minority religion groups showed less favourable outcomes across several areas.

Among the minority ethnic groups studied, Irish Travellers had the highest share reporting:

  • a disability;
  • poor general health; and
  • economic inactivity.

Across the minority religion groups in focus, the Muslim group generally had less positive outcomes. This included the highest share living in overcrowded accommodation and the lowest employment rate. The Muslim population also had the highest share reporting low English language proficiency.

Understanding the differences after taking other factors into account - Statistical modelling

Record-level data from the 2021 Census (with identifying information removed) was used for further analysis. The focus was solely ethnic groups due to limited religion data breakdowns and low numbers in some minority religion groups. Statistical modelling accounted for differences between ethnic groups in relevant characteristics (e.g. age, educational qualifications, urban or rural residence) when looking at key outcomes. Differences in outcomes between minority ethnic groups and the comparator White group were still evident.

Positive outcomes

The Chinese, Filipino and Indian groups were the minority ethnic groups least likely to report a disability, poor general health, and a mental health condition, compared to the White group.

Within the working-age population aged 16 to 64 years, the Roma, Filipino, and Black Other groups were more likely to be economically active (i.e. participating in the labour market) compared to the White group.

Analysis of economically active people aged 16 to 64 years showed that employment rates varied by ethnic group. Compared with the White group, the Roma group were 1.7 times and the Filipino group 1.5 times more likely to be in employment.

The Chinese and Indian groups were more likely than the White group to live in owner-occupied housing.

Negative outcomes

The Irish Traveller group was more than twice as likely as the White group to report a disability, poor general health, and a mental health condition.

Model estimates showed that the Roma group was more than twice as likely to report a disability relative to the White group. In contrast, the observed self-reported disability rate for each group (aged 16 years and over) was similar, i.e. 29% and 27% for the White and Roma group, respectively. This shows the value of the 2021 Census record-level data in providing more detailed insights via statistical modelling.

Among the working-age population aged 16 to 64 years, the Irish Traveller and Arab groups were much less likely to be economically active compared to the White group.

Based on those aged 16 to 64 years and economically active, eight of the 12 minority ethnic groups in focus were less likely to be in employment than the White group.

Among people with degree-level and above qualifications, the Black Other, Filipino and Black African groups were more likely than the White group to work in low-skilled jobs. This is referred to as underemployment.


Background

Northern Ireland has become increasingly diverse over recent decades. Minority ethnic communities, including Chinese, Indian and Irish Traveller populations, have long been part of society. Migration from outside Northern Ireland, particularly since the early 2000s, has contributed to much demographic change. As a result, the size and diversity of minority ethnic and minority religion communities have grown substantially, as shown in recent censuses.

Northern Ireland remains the least ethnically diverse part of the UK and the island of Ireland. Based on the most recent census round (2021 and 2022), the minority ethnic share of the population was 19.0% in England, 6.9% in Scotland, 6.2% in Wales, and no lower than 7.4% in Ireland. The corresponding figure for Northern Ireland was 3.4%.

During this time, there have also been changes in laws and policies relating to racial equality. As of summer 2026, officials from The Executive Office are developing a new approach to racial equality in Northern Ireland. The Draft Framework for Race Relations and its associated two-year Delivery Plan aim to tackle inequalities and help create a more prosperous society for everyone.


Purpose

There is a need for better evidence on outcomes for minority groups in Northern Ireland. This will help inform the development of the new Draft Framework for Race Relations and Delivery Plan.

This research uses data from the 2021 Census to investigate key socioeconomic and self-reported health outcomes for minority ethnic and minority religion groups in Northern Ireland.

The findings will help inform targeted actions to support racial equality. They will also help ensure that future policy decisions are based on strong evidence. The use of the Census 2021 Comprehensive Microdata (C21CM) is an important part of this research. These data provide more detail than the publicly-available information from the Census and allow for deeper analysis of outcomes across population groups.

This is a summary version of the main research report, also available on NISRA-led research. It provides a brief overview of the data and analysis, and highlights some key findings from the main report with supporting charts included in places. The report briefly considers the policy relevance of the findings, highlights limitations of the analysis, and identifies areas for further research.

Readers are encouraged to consult the main report for further context, detailed analysis, and commentary on differences across ethnic and religion groups.


Key definitions and population groups

There is no statutory definition of minority ethnic group. The term is generally understood in official and research contexts in Northern Ireland to refer to people who identify with an ethnic group other than the largest White group.

The 12 minority ethnic groups examined were based on the most detailed classification used for reporting 2021 Census statistics. These are the ethnic groups with a tick-box on the 2021 Census questionnaire plus any with a population count greater than that of the smallest ‘tick-box’ group:

  • Arab
  • Black African
  • Black Other
  • Chinese
  • Filipino
  • Indian
  • Irish Traveller
  • Mixed ethnic group
  • Other Asian
  • Other ethnic group
  • Pakistani
  • Roma

The White ethnic group was used as the comparison group for the ethnic group analysis.

There is also no legal definition of minority religion groups in Northern Ireland. For this research, the groups are based on people who reported a non-Christian current religion in the 2021 Census. Those who reported having no religion or did not state a religion were not included among the minority religion groups.

Six minority religion groups were examined:

  • Buddhist
  • Hindu
  • Muslim
  • Jewish
  • Sikh
  • Other religions (combined group of other non-Christian religions)

The Christian religion groups, people with no religion, and people who did not state a religion were combined to form the majority comparison group for the religion analysis.


Data source

The research was based on data from the 2021 Census of population and housing conducted by Northern Ireland Statistics and Research Agency. The Flexible Table Builder provided aggregated statistics for descriptive analysis, and the C21CM enabled statistical modelling of key outcomes.


Analysis

The analysis had two main stages.

First, descriptive analysis looked at differences between minority ethnic and minority religion groups across a range of 2021 Census variables. These included age, sex, country of birth, economic activity and housing tenure. Age-standardisation allowed meaningful comparisons of the extent of self-reported disability and poor general health between groups, by accounting for the influence of age.

Second, regression modelling was carried out using the C21CM. This focused on several key outcomes, a subset of which are presented in this summary report, namely:

  • self-reported disability
  • self-reported poor general heath
  • self-reported mental health condition
  • in employment
  • underemployed (highly-qualified and working in a low-skilled occupation)
  • living in owner-occupied housing
  • living in social rented housing

The modelling applies to ethnic group only as detailed religion information in the C21CM was unavailable due to limited religion breakdowns and small population sizes.

Regression modelling takes account of differences in demographic, socioeconomic and area characteristics between groups. This provides a clearer picture of whether differences in outcomes remained after these factors were considered. The relevant characteristics accounted for included age, sex, economic activity (e.g. employed, unemployed), educational qualifications (yes/no), household composition (e.g. single family, one-person), and urban or rural location.

The results measure the likelihood of each outcome for the minority ethnic groups compared to the White ethnic group. To highlight the key findings in this summary report, the modelling results presented in the next section include only those minority ethnic groups with the highest and lowest likelihood of the outcome relative to the White ethnic group. Complete model results showing all the ethnic groups in focus are available in the main report.


Summary of findings

Demographics

Ethnic group

  • Minority ethnic groups made up 3.4% of Northern Ireland’s population in the 2021 Census (Figure 1). This was around 65,600 people.


Figure 1: Northern Ireland’s population by broad ethnic group based on the 2021 Census.

Source: NISRA 2021 Census Flexible Table Builder

Figure 1 tabs
Chart
Data
Ethnic group Population Population (%)
White ethnic group 1,837,575 96.6
Minority ethnic groups 65,604 3.4
End tabs


  • The minority ethnic share of the population has increased over time:

    • 1.8% in the 2011 Census, around 32,400 people
    • 0.8% in the 2001 Census, around 14,300 people
  • Based on the most recent census round, Northern Ireland had the lowest minority ethnic population share when compared with the other parts of the UK (19.0% in England, 6.9% in Scotland, and 6.2% in Wales) and Ireland (at least 7.4%, as ‘Not stated’ included as a category in the ethnic group estimates). Note that the censuses in Scotland and Ireland were held in 2022, one year later than in England, Wales, and Northern Ireland.

  • In the 2021 Census, the Mixed ethnic group was the largest minority ethnic group. It made up 21.9% of Northern Ireland’s minority ethnic population, around 14,400 people (Figure 2). The next largest groups were:

    • Indian: 15.1%, around 9,900 people
    • Chinese: 14.5%, around 9,500 people
  • Of the 12 minority ethnic groups used for statistical reporting, the Roma and Pakistani groups were the smallest. Each made up just under 2.5% of the minority ethnic population, around 1,600 people.


Figure 2: Breakdown of Northern Ireland’s minority ethnic population by the 12 groups in focus, based on the 2021 Census.

Source: NISRA 2021 Census Flexible Table Builder

Figure 2 tabs
Chart
Data
Ethnic group Population Minority ethnic population (%)
Mixed ethnic group 14,382 21.9
Indian 9,881 15.1
Chinese 9,495 14.5
Black African 8,069 12.3
Other Asian 5,244 8.0
Filipino 4,451 6.8
Other ethnic group 3,568 5.4
Black Other 2,963 4.5
Irish Traveller 2,609 4.0
Arab 1,817 2.8
Pakistani 1,596 2.4
Roma 1,529 2.3
End tabs


  • There were clear patterns and differences across the minority ethnic groups in focus with regard to demographic characteristics. Regarding age structure, adults in their 30s accounted for the largest numbers in most groups. Some groups, particularly Black African and Filipino, were distinctive in terms of a small population share aged over 70 years.


Religion

  • The proportion of the population reporting a minority religion in Northern Ireland’s 2021 Census was 1.3%, around 25,500 people (Figure 3).


Figure 3: Northern Ireland’s population by broad religion group based on the 2021 Census.

Source: NISRA 2021 Census Flexible Table Builder

Figure 3 tabs
Chart
Data
Religion Population Population (%)
Christian 1,516,147 79.7
No religion 330,983 17.4
Religion not stated 30,529 1.6
Minority religions 25,518 1.3
End tabs


  • The minority religion share of Northern Ireland’s population has risen over recent decades:

    • 0.8% in the 2011 Census, around 14,900 people
    • 0.3% in the 2001 Census, around 5,000 people
  • Minority religions made up a smaller share of the population in Northern Ireland compared to the other parts of the UK (11.0% in England, 3.8% in Scotland, and 3.6% in Wales) and Ireland (3.0%), based on the 2021/2022 Censuses.

  • As shown in Figure 4, the largest individual minority religion groups in the 2021 Census were:

    • Muslim: 42.6% of the minority religion population, around 10,900 people
    • Hindu: 16.4%, around 4,200 people
    • Buddhist: 6.0%, around 1,500 people
  • Less than 2% of the minority religion population (around 400 people) reported their current religion as either Jewish or Sikh.


Figure 4: Breakdown of Northern Ireland’s minority religion population by the six groups in focus, based on the 2021 Census.

Source: NISRA 2021 Census Flexible Table Builder and commissioned table CT0150

Figure 4 tabs
Chart
Data
Religion Population Population (%)
Muslim 10,870 42.6
Other religions 8,094 31.7
Hindu 4,190 16.4
Buddhist 1,542 6.0
Jewish 439 1.7
Sikh 387 1.5
End tabs


  • Demographic characteristics varied across the minority religion groups in focus. As an example, there was variation in the age structure. The Muslim group had the youngest age profile, with just over half its population aged under 30 years. In contrast, only around one-fifth (21%) of the Jewish group were aged under 30 years.


Disability and Health

Ethnic group

  • Most minority ethnic groups reported better health outcomes than the White group after applying age-standardisation. The Filipino, Indian, and Chinese groups generally had the lowest rates of self-reported disability (45% to 65% lower) and poor general health (59% to 89% lower) relative to the White group.
  • However, poor outcomes were evident for some groups. The observed self-reported disability rate among the Irish Traveller population was 43%, compared to 25% for the White group (Table 2). After age-standardisation, the extent of poor general health among Irish Travellers was over four times that of the White group.
  • The modelling results mirrored these findings (Figure 5). The Filipino, Indian, and Chinese groups were consistently among those with the lowest likelihood of reporting a disability, poor general health, and a mental health condition relative to the White group.
  • The Irish Traveller group was over twice as likely to report a disability, poor general health, and a mental health condition compared to the White group. Notably, people in the Roma group were also over twice as likely than White group members to report a disability. This contrasts with the descriptive findings, which showed similar self-reported disability rates among the Roma and White groups aged 16 years and over (27% and 29%, respectively). This shows the value of the C21CM in supporting statistical modelling, revealing important differences after accounting for variation in population characteristics.


Figure 5: Minority ethnic groups most and least likely to report a disability, poor general health, and a mental health condition compared to the White ethnic group.

Source: Census 2021 Comprehensive Microdata

Charts
Data
Ethnic group % difference in likelihood of outcome (disability)
Irish Traveller 120
Roma 117
Filipino -54
Chinese -71
Ethnic group % difference in likelihood of outcome (poor general health)
Irish Traveller 121
Chinese -73
Filipino -79
Ethnic group % difference in likelihood of outcome (mental health condition)
Irish Traveller 122
Indian -77
Chinese -82


Note: Results are based on people aged 16 years and over recorded in the 2021 Census. The bold line represents the reference White ethnic group. A positive estimate (i.e. to the right of the reference line) indicates a higher likelihood of the outcome compared to the White group. A negative estimate (i.e. to the left of the reference line) indicates a lower likelihood of the outcome compared to the White group. The estimates have been adjusted for differences in relevant characteristics between groups, enabling a like-for-like comparison.
To make the findings easier to understand, minority ethnic groups with a higher likelihood are shown as ‘times more likely’, while groups with a lower likelihood are shown as a percentage less likely. This helps to clearly show the size of the differences between groups.



Religion

  • Similar variation in disability and health-related outcomes was observed among minority religion groups.
  • The Hindu population had lower rates of both self-reported disability and poor general health. The self-reported disability rate was 8%, compared with 24% for the comparator Christian/No religion/Not stated group (Table 2). Similarly, just 2% of the Hindu population reported poor general health, compared with 8% of the comparator group (Table 2).
  • Applying age-standardisation, the incidence of self-reported poor general health was higher among the Other religions (by 14%) and Muslim (by 34%) groups (Figure 6).


Figure 6: Self-reported poor general health among minority religion groups compared to the Christian/No religion/Not stated group, after accounting for differences in age.

Source: NISRA 2021 Census Flexible Table Builder

Chart
Data
Religion Age standardised ratio - Self reported poor general health
Buddhist 0.93
Hindu 0.35
Muslim 1.14
Other religions* 1.34


Note: The results take account of differences in age profiles between religion groups. This allows a fair comparison, as poor health is generally more common among older people. Values above 1 indicate poorer self-reported general health than the Christian/No religion/Not stated reference group. For example, 1.5 means the rate is one and a half times higher. Values below 1 indicate better self-reported general health. For example, 0.5 means the rate is half that of the reference group.


Qualifications and economic activity

Ethnic group

  • Education and employment outcomes varied across minority ethnic groups.

  • As shown in Table 1, some groups had higher shares with degree-level and above qualifications than the White group (32%), notably:

    • the Indian group (70%)
    • the Filipino group (66%)
  • Other groups had high proportions reporting no formal qualifications. Almost 80% of the Roma group and 67% of the Irish Traveller group reported having no formal qualifications. This is compared to 24% of the White group (Table 2).

  • Some minority ethnic groups had high employment rates. Among the Filipino group, 80% of both adult females and males were in employment. The corresponding figures for the White group were 52% of females and 60% of males.

  • Employment rates were much lower for the Irish Traveller group:

    • 21% for males
    • 16% for females
  • There were also differences in the type of jobs people worked in. Around six in ten of the Indian group and one in ten of the Roma and Black Other groups worked in high-skilled jobs; this compares to three in ten of the White group (Table 1). Within the Roma and Black Other groups, around three in ten had low-skilled occupations, versus one in ten of the White group (Table 2).

  • The modelling results show that of people aged 16 to 64 years who were economically active, the Roma (73% more likely) and Filipino (48% more likely) groups had the highest likelihood of employment compared to the White group (Figure 7). In contrast, the Arab (68% less likely) and Irish Traveller (57% less likely) groups were the least likely to be employed relative to the White group.

  • Note that this model should be considered alongside the other economic activity models in the main research report. Together, they provide a broad picture of economic activity and employment for minority ethnic group members aged 16 to 64 years at the time of the 2021 Census. Other results show that the Roma, Filipino, and Black Other groups were more likely to be economically active (i.e. participating in the labour market) compared to the White group. In contrast, the Irish Traveller and Arab groups were much less likely to be economically active.


Figure 7: Minority ethnic groups most and least likely to be in employment compared to the White ethnic group.

Source: Census 2021 Comprehensive Microdata

Chart
Data
Ethnic group % difference in likelihood of outcome (employment)
Roma 73
Filipino 48
Irish Traveller -57
Arab -68


Note: Results are based on people aged 16 to 64 years who reported being economically active at the time of the 2021 Census (i.e. either in employment, or unemployed and looking for work). The bold line represents the reference White ethnic group. A positive estimate (i.e. to the right of the reference line) indicates a higher likelihood of being employed compared to the White group. A negative estimate (i.e. to the left of the reference line) indicates a lower likelihood of being employed compared to the White group. The estimates have been adjusted for differences in relevant characteristics between groups, enabling a like-for-like comparison.
To make the findings easier to understand, minority ethnic groups with a higher likelihood are shown as ‘times more likely’, while groups with a lower likelihood are shown as a percentage less likely. This helps to clearly show the size of the differences between groups.



  • The modelling analysis indicates that underemployment was most likely among the Black Other (2.2 times) and Filipino (1.8 times) groups relative to the White group (Figure 8). This means that people in these groups with degree-level and above qualifications had a higher likelihood of working in low-skilled jobs.


Figure 8: Minority ethnic groups most and least likely to be underemployed compared to the White ethnic group.

Source: Census 2021 Comprehensive Microdata

Chart
Data
Ethnic group % difference in likelihood of outcome (underemployed)
Black Other 118
Filipino 80
Chinese -19
Indian -31


Note: Results are based on people aged 16 to 64 years with at least a degree-level qualification who were employed at the time of the 2021 Census. The bold line represents the reference White ethnic group. A positive estimate (i.e. to the right of the reference line) indicates a higher likelihood of working in a low-skilled occupation compared to the White group. A negative estimate (i.e. to the left of the reference line) indicates a lower likelihood of working in a low-skilled occupation compared to the White group. The estimates have been adjusted for differences in relevant characteristics between groups, enabling a like-for-like comparison.
To make the findings easier to understand, minority ethnic groups with a higher likelihood are shown as ‘times more likely’, while groups with a lower likelihood are shown as a percentage less likely. This helps to clearly show the size of the differences between groups.



Religion

  • As shown in Figure 9, three-quarters of the Hindu population had degree-level and above qualifications. This compares with around one in three people in the Christian/No religion/Not stated group. Almost one-third of the Muslim population had no formal qualifications.


Figure 9: Qualifications status by religion group based on the 2021 Census.

Source: NISRA 2021 Census Flexible Table Builder and commissioned table CT0150

Figure 9 tabs
Chart
Data
Religion No qualifications (%) Below degree level (%) Other qualifications (%) Degree level and above (%) Total population (age 16+ years)
Buddhist 20 25 8 47 1,441
Christian/No religion/Not stated 24 36 9 32 1,495,058
Hindu 7 12 6 75 3,169
Jewish 11 33 2 55 400
Muslim 32 22 9 38 7,391
Other religions 20 33 9 38 6,977
Sikh 27 21 5 48 305
End tabs

Note: Labels on chart bars are percentages.



  • Economic activity within minority religion groups varied by gender. For example, 63% of Muslim females were economically inactive, compared to 42% of Muslim males (Figure 10). Among the Hindu group, the corresponding figures were 36% of females and 19% of males.


Figure 10: Economic activity status by religion group and sex based on the 2021 Census.

Source: NISRA 2021 Census Flexible Table Builder

Figure 10 tabs
Charts
Female Data
Religion Employee (%) Self-employed (%) Unemployed (%) Economically inactive (%) Total population (age 16+ years)
Buddhist 44 10 4 41 844
Christian/No religion/Not stated 48 4 2 45 768,225
Hindu 52 5 7 36 1,429
Muslim 28 4 6 63 3,078
Other religions* 40 8 3 49 4,036
* Includes the Jewish and Sikh groups
Male Data
Religion Employee (%) Self-employed (%) Unemployed (%) Economically inactive (%) Total population (age 16+ years)
Buddhist 49 11 7 33 598
Christian/No religion/Not stated 47 13 3 37 726,844
Hindu 67 7 6 19 1,738
Muslim 39 12 8 42 4,316
Other religions* 42 13 4 41 3,647
* Includes the Jewish and Sikh groups
End tabs


Note: Labels on chart bars are percentages.


Housing

Ethnic group

  • There were differences in housing outcomes across ethnic groups, especially relating to housing tenure and overcrowding.

  • Around 70% of the White ethnic group lived in owner-occupied housing. This was much lower for the Roma group, of whom 10% lived in owner-occupied housing and 71% lived in private rented housing.

  • The Irish Traveller group had a distinct housing profile, with 55% living in social rented housing.

  • Overcrowding was higher for some groups. Within the Roma population, 68% lived in overcrowded housing. This was more than four times the rate for the White group, at 15% (Table 2).

  • The modelling results in Figure 11 show that the Chinese and Indian groups were the most likely to live in owner-occupied housing compared to the White group:

    • Chinese: 1.7 times more likely
    • Indian: 1.4 times more likely
  • The Roma and Irish Traveller groups were the least likely to live in owner-occupied housing compared to the White group:

    • Roma: 88% less likely
    • Irish Traveller: 79% less likely


Figure 11: Minority ethnic groups most and least likely to be living in owner-occupied housing compared to the White ethnic group.

Source: Census 2021 Comprehensive Microdata

Chart
Data
Ethnic group % difference in likelihood of outcome (owner-occupied housing)
Chinese 69
Indian 36
Irish Traveller -79
Roma -88


Note: Results are based on people usually resident in households in the 2021 Census. People whose usual residence was a caravan, mobile home or other temporary structure on Census Day were enumerated as part of the usual resident population. The bold line represents the reference White ethnic group. A positive estimate (i.e. to the right of the reference line) indicates a higher likelihood of living in owner-occupied housing compared to the White group. A negative estimate (i.e. to the left of the reference line) indicates a lower likelihood of living in owner-occupied housing compared to the White group. The estimates have been adjusted for differences in relevant characteristics between groups, enabling a like-for-like comparison.
To make the findings easier to understand, minority ethnic groups with a higher likelihood are shown as ‘times more likely’, while groups with a lower likelihood are shown as a percentage less likely. This helps to clearly show the size of the differences between groups.



  • The model results in Figure 12 show that people in the Irish Traveller group were over four and a half times more likely than the White group population to be living in social-rented housing. For the Arab group, the likelihood of living in social-rented housing was over three times that of the White group. This housing outcome was least likely for the Indian and Pakistani groups.


Figure 12: Minority ethnic groups most and least likely to be living in social-rented housing compared to the White ethnic group.

Source: Census 2021 Comprehensive Microdata

Chart
Data
Ethnic group % difference in likelihood of outcome (social-rented housing)
Arab 217
Irish Traveller 363
Indian -75
Pakistani -55


Note: Results are based on people usually resident in households in the 2021 Census. People whose usual residence was a caravan, mobile home or other temporary structure on Census Day were enumerated as part of the usual resident population. The bold line represents the reference White ethnic group. A positive estimate (i.e. to the right of the reference line) indicates a higher likelihood of living in social-renting housing compared to the White group. A negative estimate (i.e. to the left of the reference line) indicates a lower likelihood of living in social-rented housing compared to the White group. The estimates have been adjusted for differences in relevant characteristics between groups, enabling a like-for-like comparison.
To make the findings easier to understand, minority ethnic groups with a higher likelihood are shown as ‘times more likely’, while groups with a lower likelihood are shown as a percentage less likely. This helps to clearly show the size of the differences between groups.



Religion

  • Differences in housing outcomes were also evident across religion groups.
  • Around one-quarter of Muslim people lived in owner-occupied housing, compared with 69% of people in the Christian/No religion/Not stated group (Figure 13).


Figure 13: Housing tenure status by religion group based on the 2021 Census.

Source: NISRA 2021 Census Flexible Table Builder and commissioned table CT0150

Figure 10 tabs
Chart
Data
Religion Owner occupied (%) Private rented (%) Social rented (%) Lives rent free (%) Total population
Buddhist 58 32 9 1 1,463
Christian/No religion/Not stated 69 16 13 2 1,852,058
Hindu 52 46 2 0 4,039
Jewish 62 25 11 2 429
Muslim 26 37 31 6 10,562
Other religions 59 23 15 3 7,903
Sikh 73 22 3 2 374
End tabs

Note: Labels on chart bars are percentages.



  • Just under 40% of the Muslim group and 30% of the Hindu group were estimated to be living in overcrowded housing. For the Christian/No religion/Not stated group, the corresponding figure was much lower at 15% (Table 2).


Key outcome disparities

Tables 1 and 2 provide a visual summary of the descriptive findings. They show the difference in percentage points when comparing each minority group with the comparator group based on the population share associated with key outcomes. As a reminder, the comparator ethnic group is the White group, while for religion the comparator is the Christian/No religion/Not stated group.

The green and pink shading indicate the minority group having a better or worse outcome, respectively, based on the general perception of the outcome being positive or negative. The positive outcomes are:

  • Highest qualification of degree level and above
  • Employed
  • High-skilled occupation

The negative outcomes are:

  • Self-reported disability
  • Self-reported poor general health
  • Providing unpaid care for 50 or more hours per week
  • Having no formal qualifications
  • Low English language proficiency
  • Economically inactive
  • Low-skilled occupation
  • Living in overcrowded accommodation

Outcomes varied considerably between both minority ethnic and minority religion groups, revealing a mixed picture overall.

Some minority groups had more positive outcomes in education and employment. For example, the Indian and Filipino ethnic groups, and Hindu religion group, had high levels of qualifications and strong labour market participation. These groups also had relatively positive health outcomes. These patterns may be partly linked to the younger age profile of some groups. They may also be linked to migration for work and to the migration of people with higher qualifications.

Some minority groups experienced less favourable outcomes. This was most evident for the Irish Traveller and Roma ethnic groups, who had poorer outcomes in areas including:

  • education;
  • employment;
  • health; and
  • housing (overcrowding).

This suggests that disadvantage may build up across different areas for these groups.

Overcrowded accommodation was one of the most common issues identified. Relative to the comparator groups, the outcome was associated with a larger share of all minority ethnic groups and with five of the six minority religion groups in focus.

For other minority groups, poorer outcomes were more focused in specific areas. For example, the Arab ethnic group and Muslim religion group had lower levels of English language proficiency and higher levels of economic inactivity.

Note that around 85% of the Arab ethnic group reported Muslim as their religion in the 2021 Census. The similar outcomes observed for both groups show that while ethnic group and religion are different parts of a person’s cultural identity, they are often closely linked.


Table 1: Summary table comparing minority ethnic and minority religion groups with the comparator White ethnic group and Christian/No religion/Not stated religion group, respectively, across perceived positive outcomes.

Source: NISRA Census 2021 Flexible Table Builder and commissioned table CT0150

Tables
Ethnic group Degree level and above qualifications Employed High-skilled occupation
Arab +10 -28 +19
Black African +13 +2 +2
Black Other -10 +14 -17
Chinese +5 -13 +1
Filipino +35 +24 +21
Indian +39 +12 +32
Irish Traveller -21 -38 -1
Mixed ethnic group +9 +4 +1
Other Asian +3 +1 -6
Other ethnic group +4 +3 -5
Pakistani +21 -1 +19
Roma -26 +12 -19
Religion group Degree level and above qualifications Employed High-skilled occupation
Buddhist +15 +1 +2
Hindu +43 +10 +34
Jewish +23 -1 +12
Muslim +6 -14 +6
Sikh +16 +4 +9
Other religions +6 -5 0
Data
Ethnic group Degree level and above qualifications Employed High-skilled occupation
White (comparator group) 466,074 (32%) 822,598 (56%) 238,677 (29%)
Arab 524 (41%, +10pp) 354 (28%, -28pp) 171 (48%, +19pp)
Black African 2,540 (44%, +13pp) 3,298 (58%, +2pp) 1,013 (31%, +2pp)
Black Other 458 (21%, -10pp) 1,494 (70%, +14pp) 173 (12%, -17pp)
Chinese 2,957 (37%, +5pp) 3,477 (43%, -13pp) 1,057 (30%, +1pp)
Filipino 2,418 (66%, +35pp) 2,924 (80%, +24pp) 1,464 (50%, +21pp)
Indian 5,231 (70%, +39pp) 5,056 (68%, +12pp) 3,096 (61%, +32pp)
Irish Traveller 185 (11%, -21pp) 308 (18%, -38pp) 86 (28%, -1pp)
Mixed ethnic group 2,841 (41%, +9pp) 4,198 (60%, +4pp) 1,245 (30%, +1pp)
Other Asian 1,407 (35%, +3pp) 2,336 (57%, +1pp) 540 (23%, -6pp)
Other ethnic group 1,003 (35%, +4pp) 1,684 (59%, +3pp) 401 (24%, -5pp)
Pakistani 635 (53%, +21pp) 658 (55%, -1pp) 319 (48%, +19pp)
Roma 60 (6%, -26pp) 714 (68%, +12pp) 74 (10%, -19pp)
Note:
Values are presented as outcome (% share, % point difference from the White comparator group).
2021 Census current religion Degree level and above qualifications Employed High-skilled occupation
Christian/No religion or Not stated (comparator group) 477,474 (32%) 839,116 (56%) 244,451 (29%)
Buddhist 674 (47%, +15pp) 821 (57%, +1pp) 255 (31%, +2pp)
Hindu 2,385 (75%, +43pp) 2,100 (66%, +10pp) 1,334 (63%, +34pp)
Jewish 218 (55%, +23pp) 222 (55%, -1pp) 90 (41%, +12pp)
Muslim 2,803 (38%, +6pp) 3,139 (42%, -14pp) 1,104 (35%, +6pp)
Sikh 145 (48%, +16pp) 184 (60%, +4pp) 70 (38%, +9pp)
Other religions 2,630 (38%, +6pp) 3,935 (51%, -5pp) 1,014 (29%, -0pp)
Note:
Values are presented as outcome (% share, % point difference from the Christian/No religion or Not stated comparator group).


Note: Darker shading indicates a greater difference in the population share (%) associated with the outcome compared to the comparator group. Green and pink signify more or less favourable, respectively.


Table 2: Summary table comparing minority ethnic and minority religion groups with the comparator White ethnic group and Christian/No religion/Not stated religion group, respectively, across perceived negative outcomes.

Source: NISRA Census 2021 Flexible Table Builder and commissioned table CT0150

Tables
Ethnic group Disability Poor general health Unpaid care 50+ hours per week No qualifications Low English proficiency Economically inactive Low-skilled occupation Overcrowding
Arab -8 -1 0 +10 +30 +24 -2 +24
Black African -16 -6 -3 -3 +11 -6 +7 +25
Black Other -16 -6 -3 +25 +13 -16 +23 +33
Chinese -14 -5 -3 +8 +21 +12 +4 +7
Filipino -19 -7 -2 -15 0 -24 +2 +13
Indian -17 -5 -3 -16 +2 -15 -3 +11
Irish Traveller +18 +13 +1 +43 0 +37 +3 +24
Mixed ethnic group -12 -5 -3 -7 +2 -8 +4 +11
Other Asian -15 -5 -2 +10 +15 -4 +13 +25
Other ethnic group -7 -1 -1 +7 +12 -6 +8 +14
Pakistani -13 -4 -2 -6 +3 -1 -3 +14
Roma -2 -4 -3 +55 +42 -16 +19 +54
Religion group Disability Poor general health Unpaid care 50+ hours per week No qualifications Low English proficiency Economically inactive Low-skilled occupation Overcrowding
Buddhist -5 -1 -1 -4 +6 -3 +2 +3
Hindu -16 -6 -3 -17 +2 -14 -4 +15
Jewish +3 +17 0 -13 -1 -1 -2 -6
Muslim -9 -3 -1 +8 +17 +10 +4 +23
Sikh -12 +6 -2 +3 +4 -8 +1 +2
Other religions +2 +2 +1 -4 +2 +4 +1 +3
Data
Ethnic group Disability Poor general health Unpaid care 50+ hours per week No qualifications Low English proficiency Economically inactive Low-skilled occupation Overcrowding
White (comparator group) 455,005 (25%) 143,717 (8%) 67,628 (4%) 348,767 (24%) 13,635 (1%) 606,497 (41%) 80,295 (10%) 263,560 (15%)
Arab 305 (17%, -8pp) 136 (7%, -1pp) 72 (4%, +0pp) 438 (34%, +10pp) 531 (31%, +30pp) 834 (66%, +24pp) 29 (8%, -2pp) 662 (38%, +24pp)
Black African 754 (9%, -16pp) 176 (2%, -6pp) 95 (1%, -3pp) 1,227 (21%, -3pp) 933 (12%, +11pp) 2,015 (35%, -6pp) 563 (17%, +7pp) 3,055 (39%, +25pp)
Black Other 266 (9%, -16pp) 73 (2%, -6pp) 36 (1%, -3pp) 1,037 (49%, +25pp) 402 (14%, +13pp) 546 (26%, -16pp) 482 (32%, +23pp) 1,392 (48%, +33pp)
Chinese 1,034 (11%, -14pp) 270 (3%, -5pp) 107 (1%, -3pp) 2,575 (32%, +8pp) 2,062 (22%, +21pp) 4,292 (53%, +12pp) 479 (14%, +4pp) 1,666 (22%, +7pp)
Filipino 278 (6%, -19pp) 32 (1%, -7pp) 78 (2%, -2pp) 331 (9%, -15pp) 30 (1%, -0pp) 622 (17%, -24pp) 352 (12%, +2pp) 1,203 (27%, +13pp)
Indian 745 (8%, -17pp) 171 (2%, -5pp) 109 (1%, -3pp) 610 (8%, -16pp) 273 (3%, +2pp) 1,951 (26%, -15pp) 322 (6%, -3pp) 2,462 (26%, +11pp)
Irish Traveller 1,123 (43%, +18pp) 543 (21%, +13pp) 125 (5%, +1pp) 1,123 (67%, +43pp) 17 (1%, -0pp) 1,318 (78%, +37pp) 40 (13%, +3pp) 982 (38%, +24pp)
Mixed ethnic group 1,815 (13%, -12pp) 403 (3%, -5pp) 177 (1%, -3pp) 1,173 (17%, -7pp) 390 (3%, +2pp) 2,341 (34%, -8pp) 587 (14%, +4pp) 3,576 (25%, +11pp)
Other Asian 505 (10%, -15pp) 148 (3%, -5pp) 100 (2%, -2pp) 1,422 (35%, +10pp) 788 (16%, +15pp) 1,525 (37%, -4pp) 534 (23%, +13pp) 1,979 (40%, +25pp)
Other ethnic group 637 (18%, -7pp) 240 (7%, -1pp) 114 (3%, -1pp) 874 (31%, +7pp) 443 (13%, +12pp) 1,012 (36%, -6pp) 305 (18%, +8pp) 972 (28%, +14pp)
Pakistani 197 (12%, -13pp) 63 (4%, -4pp) 35 (2%, -2pp) 221 (18%, -6pp) 66 (4%, +3pp) 488 (40%, -1pp) 42 (6%, -3pp) 432 (28%, +14pp)
Roma 353 (23%, -2pp) 61 (4%, -4pp) 17 (1%, -3pp) 826 (79%, +55pp) 604 (43%, +42pp) 268 (26%, -16pp) 208 (29%, +19pp) 1,039 (68%, +54pp)
Note:
Values are presented as outcome (% share, % point difference from the White comparator group).
2021 Census current religion Disability Poor general health Unpaid care 50+ hours per week No qualifications Low English proficiency Economically inactive Low-skilled occupation Overcrowding
Christian/No religion or Not stated (comparator group) 458,037 (24%) 144,366 (8%) 67,940 (4%) 356,253 (24%) 17,856 (1%) 615,085 (41%) 83,170 (10%) 275,887 (15%)
Buddhist 295 (19%, -5pp) 105 (7%, -1pp) 45 (3%, -1pp) 295 (20%, -4pp) 105 (7%, +6pp) 545 (38%, -3pp) 102 (12%, +2pp) 268 (18%, +3pp)
Hindu 322 (8%, -16pp) 70 (2%, -6pp) 37 (1%, -3pp) 212 (7%, -17pp) 111 (3%, +2pp) 851 (27%, -14pp) 117 (6%, -4pp) 1,215 (30%, +15pp)
Jewish 120 (27%, +3pp) 108 (25%, +17pp) 18 (4%, +0pp) 43 (11%, -13pp) 1 (0%, -1pp) 161 (40%, -1pp) 17 (8%, -2pp) 39 (9%, -6pp)
Muslim 1,601 (15%, -9pp) 530 (5%, -3pp) 260 (3%, -1pp) 2,334 (32%, +8pp) 1,851 (18%, +17pp) 3,750 (51%, +10pp) 433 (14%, +4pp) 4,054 (38%, +23pp)
Sikh 48 (12%, -12pp) 53 (14%, +6pp) 9 (2%, -2pp) 83 (27%, +3pp) 19 (5%, +4pp) 101 (33%, -8pp) 21 (11%, +1pp) 65 (17%, +2pp)
Other religions 2,103 (26%, +2pp) 797 (10%, +2pp) 381 (5%, +1pp) 1,405 (20%, -4pp) 226 (3%, +2pp) 3,486 (45%, +4pp) 375 (11%, +1pp) 1,451 (18%, +3pp)
Note:
Values are presented as outcome (% share, % point difference from the Christian/No religion or Not stated comparator group).


Note: Darker shading indicates a greater difference in the population share (%) associated with the outcome compared to the comparator group. Green and pink signify more or less favourable, respectively.


The modelling analysis, which allowed like-for-like comparisons, showed that differences between minority ethnic groups and the White group remained. This suggests that the differences are not fully explained by the person, household, and area-level factors considered. Other factors are likely to have influenced the outcomes examined.

The findings show the need for policy responses that recognise both:

  • issues that affect several minority groups
  • issues that are more specific to particular groups


Policy relevance

The findings show that differences between minority ethnic groups were not fully explained by the factors measured in the 2021 Census. This means that general policies for the whole population may not be enough on their own.

Targeted action may be needed for groups that experienced poorer outcomes across several areas. This was most clear for the Irish Traveller and Roma groups.

The findings point to the need for policy action across several areas, including:

  • improving educational outcomes;
  • supporting people into work;
  • reducing health inequalities;
  • supporting English language needs; and
  • tackling housing disadvantage, including overcrowding.

Overall, the evidence suggests that policy responses should include both:

  • targeted actions for minority ethnic groups experiencing poorer outcomes across several areas; and
  • wider actions to address inequalities that affect more than one group.

The findings also show differences between minority religion groups. However, the solely descriptive analysis provides less evidence on why these differences exist. This should be considered when using the findings for policy. Further research would help improve understanding of the reasons for inequalities across minority religion groups.


Limitations

The findings should be considered alongside some important limitations associated with the data and methods used in the analysis. These include:

  • A snapshot in time: The 2021 Census provides information on the population at one point in time, i.e. March 2021. It does not show how outcomes have changed for individuals or groups over time.
  • Small population sizes: Some minority ethnic and minority religion groups had small population sizes in the 2021 Census. This was particularly the case for some religion groups in focus, whose population was less than 1,000 people. Small numbers limit the level of detail that can be reported.
  • Hard-to-count groups: Evidence shows that some minority ethnic and minority religion groups may be underrepresented in census data. The likelihood is higher for groups that are more marginalised or mobile. This could affect the accuracy of estimates for these groups.
  • Limited breakdown of the White ethnic group: The ethnic group classification in Northern Ireland’s 2021 Census does not permit analysis of specific groups. Within the White ethnic group, for example, there are sub-groups of policy interest. These include arrivals from European Union Accession countries in 2004 and 2007, including Poland and Lithuania.
  • Pandemic impact: Findings relating to economic activity and employment should be interpreted with caution. The 2021 Census took place during the COVID-19 pandemic. Measures introduced in response to the pandemic, such as the Coronavirus Job Retention Scheme (furlough) and increased home working, may have affected how people reported their employment status and working arrangements.
  • Self-reported information: Information provided by people in the census is self-reported. As a result, responses may be affected by how people understand or choose to answer the questions.
  • Limits to the religion analysis: Detailed religion breakdowns were not available in the C21CM. This meant that regression modelling could not be carried out to better understand outcomes for and differences between religion groups.
  • Unobserved factors: Some important factors were not captured in the 2021 Census. For example, there is no information on barriers to accessing services. This limits what the analysis can say about the reasons for differences between both ethnic and religion groups.


Conclusion

This research highlights clear differences in outcomes across both minority ethnic and minority religion groups in Northern Ireland.

Some groups had more positive outcomes. Others experienced less favourable outcomes in several areas. This was most clear for the Irish Traveller and Roma ethnic groups, who had poorer outcomes in health, education, employment and housing.

The findings show that inequalities are not the same for all groups. Some issues (e.g. overcrowded accommodation) affected many minority groups, while others like self-reported poor general health were more specific to particular groups. This points to the need for policy responses that are targeted and based on evidence.

The research also shows the value of census data, especially census microdata for research. These data cover the whole population and provide detailed information on smaller groups that may not be well represented in other data sources. The availability of census microdata also allowed for statistical modelling. This helped show whether differences between groups remained after accounting for key individual, household and area characteristics.

The Executive Office continues to develop the draft framework and delivery plan. These findings will contribute to strengthening the evidence base required to inform and prioritise key interventions to achieve its outcomes.

Acknowledgement

Administrative Data Research - Northern Ireland (ADR-NI) takes privacy protection very seriously. All information that directly identifies individuals/organisations will be removed from the datasets by trusted third parties before researchers access them. All researchers using ADR-NI are trained and accredited to use sensitive data safely and ethically, they will only access the data via a secure environment and all their findings will be vetted to ensure they comply with strict confidentiality requirements. The help provided by the staff of the Administrative Data Research Centre - Northern Ireland (ADRC-NI) and the ADR-NI support officers within NISRA Research Support Unit (RSU) is acknowledged. ADR-NI is funded by the Economic and Social Research Council (ESRC). The authors alone are responsible for the interpretation of the data and any views or opinions presented are solely those of the author and do not necessarily represent those of ADR-NI. The Census 2021 Comprehensive Microdata has been supplied by NISRA for the sole purpose of this project.

About ADR UK

ADR UK (Administrative Data Research UK) is a partnership transforming the way researchers access the UK’s wealth of public sector data, to enable better informed policy decisions that improve people’s lives. By linking together data held by different parts of government and facilitating safe and secure access for accredited researchers to these newly joined-up and de-identified data sets, ADR UK is creating a sustainable body of knowledge about how our society and economy function – tailored to give decision makers the answers they need to solve important policy questions. ADR UK is funded by the Economic and Social Research Council (ESRC), part of UK Research and Innovation.

Contact Details

Research team: Brian Foley, Carmel Colohan, Jana Ross, Lewis Reid, John Hughes, Eoghan Bradley (all Administrative Research Unit, NISRA), and Sinéad Drumm (The Executive Office).

For further information on this research, please contact

Accessibility contact

Please contact Dissemination Branch for assistance with accessibility requirements or alternative formats. Contact details are:

Email:

Telephone: +44 (0)300 200 7836

Dissemination Branch
NISRA
Colby House
Stranmillis Court
BELFAST
BT9 5RR